The Valve lawsuit in brief
| Case | People of the State of New York v. Valve Corporation |
|---|---|
| Court | Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County (Index No. 450952/2026), before Justice Nancy M. Bannon |
| Filed | 25 February 2026 by Attorney General Letitia James (press release, complaint) |
| Games named | Counter-Strike 2, Team Fortress 2 and Dota 2 |
| What New York claims | That paying to open loot boxes such as CS2 cases is illegal gambling under the state constitution (article I, section 9) and is promoting gambling in the first and second degree under the Penal Law (sections 225.10 and 225.05), all three brought under Executive Law § 63(12); Valve's memorandum describes the same three claims in the amended complaint |
| What New York asks for | An order permanently stopping the practice, an accounting of what New Yorkers lost, restitution and damages with interest, disgorgement of Valve's gains, a fine of three times Valve's gain, and $2,000 in costs |
| Valve's answer | Valve says its cases are not gambling and that New York wants items to stop being transferable, which it refuses (Steam Support statement, 11 March 2026). On 18 May 2026 it moved to dismiss New York's first amended complaint (memorandum of law, NYSCEF doc. 20) |
| Where it stands | We found no ruling on the motion as of 18 November 2026 |
| Class actions | Players sued Valve in federal court in Seattle (Western District of Washington), among them Flauto v. Valve, No. 2:26-cv-00788, filed 9 March 2026 (complaint), and Galas v. Valve, No. 2:26-cv-00995, filed 24 March 2026 (complaint). Valve has asked that court to dismiss too; a law report of 1 October 2026 says no ruling yet (Legal 500, press), and we found none as of 18 November 2026 |
From the filings themselves: the Attorney General's complaint and press release, Valve's memorandum of law (a court filing; the copy is hosted by Courthouse News), the federal complaints and Valve's own statement. The date New York filed its amended complaint is not on any page we could read, so we do not give one.
What the Valve lawsuit means for players
- Nothing has changed yet. No court has ruled in either case that we could find as of 18 November 2026. Cases, trading and the Steam Market work as before.
- What a New York win could change. The complaint asks for a permanent order against the practice in New York. What such an order would cover is for the court to decide; Valve says the Attorney General wanted items to stop being transferable, and that it refuses.
- Third-party sites. The complaint also describes skin gambling sites that use CS2 items. The case is against Valve, not against those sites.
- Money back. The state asks for restitution for New Yorkers; the Seattle class actions ask for money back for US players who paid to open loot boxes. We found no claim process for either.
Where it stands on 18 November 2026
- United States: New York's Attorney General is suing Valve, saying CS2 cases are illegal gambling. Valve has asked the court to dismiss the case; we found no ruling as of 18 November 2026. Separate class actions against Valve are running in federal court in Seattle, where Valve has also asked the court to dismiss; we found no ruling there either.
- Tournaments: since December 2025 Valve's tournament rules require every licensed CS2 event, ranked or unranked, to follow the licence clause that bars case-opening and skin trading sponsors and any sponsor that interacts with players' Valve inventories, and ESL Pro Tour wrote a matching rule into its team rulebook in July 2026.
- Europe: in Germany and the Netherlands, cases open only through Valve's X-Ray Scanner (since 16 March 2026). The Dutch regulator ordered CSGOFast to stop serving Dutch players and moved to collect €840,000 in penalties.
- Elsewhere: Australia's regulator formally warned the companies behind CSGOFast and Skin.Club in July 2025. Brazil's child online-safety law has banned loot boxes in games likely to be used by minors since March 2026, and its Justice Ministry has flagged CS2 for monitoring. A UK government-published review says skins gambling sites are not considered legal in Great Britain.
CS2 gambling news and law, newest first
| Date | What happened | Why it matters to you | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brazil | Brazil's Justice Ministry flags CS2 loot boxes for monitoring. Brazil's Ministry of Justice published Technical Note 55/2026, asking the national data protection authority (ANPD) to prioritise monitoring six games that still sell paid loot boxes without age checks it considers sufficient. Counter-Strike 2 is one of the six. The ministry calls the note a preliminary analysis, not a finding that any company broke the law. | We found no fine or block as of 18 November 2026. Under Brazil's rules a game with loot boxes has three routes: check ages and block the feature for minors, offer a version without boxes, or switch the feature off by default for Brazilian users. Any of these could change how cases work for players in Brazil. |
|
| Esports | ESL Pro Tour adds Valve's sponsor ban to its team rulebook. ESL FACEIT Group's ESL Pro Tour Counter-Strike rulebook (2026 Update #2) changed its sponsor rules "to align with Valve sponsor restriction updates" (ESL changelog). Sponsors that violate Valve's IP, including companies that interact with players' Valve game inventories, are now prohibited for teams. | Skin gambling, case-opening and skin trading sites work with players' Steam inventories, so the rule appears to cover them at ESL Pro Tour events. Betting sponsors are covered by a separate clause of Valve's licence (2.4, Compliance). |
|
| Sites | BitSkins announces it will close, citing regulation and VAT. BitSkins, a long-running CS2 skin marketplace, announced it would close, citing tighter regulation, restrictions from authorities and heavy VAT costs, as well as Steam API limits. New deposits and listings stopped on 29 May 2026 and automated withdrawals ended on 30 June 2026. | Skin sites can close at short notice for legal and tax reasons. Keep only what you need on any site and withdraw the rest; our list of closed sites shows what happened to each one. |
On CS2Bet: Closed CS2 gambling sites · BitSkins review |
| United States | Valve asks the New York court to dismiss the case. Valve filed a motion to dismiss the Attorney General's first amended complaint in full (the filing's own title). Its 42-page filing argues that buying a case is a simple purchase rather than a bet, that a skin is not "something of value" under New York gambling law, and compares cases to packs of baseball cards. It also argues that the state constitution's gambling ban gives no claim on its own, that Valve did not knowingly promote gambling, and that New York's reading of the law would breach fair notice, the First Amendment and the separation of powers. The filing opens: "People enjoy surprises." The case is before Justice Nancy M. Bannon. | Nothing changes for players while the motion is pending, and we found no ruling as of 18 November 2026. The court's ruling on this motion, or a later trial, will decide whether CS2 cases count as gambling in New York. | |
| Brazil | Brazil's ECA Digital takes effect and bans loot boxes for minors. Brazil's Digital Statute of Children and Adolescents (Law 15.211/2025) came into force. Among other rules, its Article 20 bans loot boxes in video games aimed at, or likely to be used by, children and teenagers, judged by the game's age rating. | Players in Brazil may meet age checks or limits on cases in games that keep loot boxes. We found no Valve statement about CS2 and the Brazilian law. |
|
| Germany, Netherlands | X-Ray Scanner becomes the only way to open cases in Germany and the Netherlands. Valve gave players in Germany and the Netherlands an X-Ray Scanner tab in their inventory. For them, containers can only be opened through the scanner, which shows the item inside before you pay. Keyless containers such as Souvenir Packages still open without it. | You see the item first and then decide whether to buy it. You must first claim a free, non-tradable "Genuine P250 | X-ray", you can scan one container at a time, and you have to buy the revealed item before you can scan another. A scanned container is used up and cannot be traded or sold. |
On CS2Bet: CS2 cases |
| United States | Valve answers New York in a public statement. Valve published a statement to its New York players saying its cases do not break New York law. It says it has locked over one million Steam accounts misused by third parties for gambling, fraud and theft, and forbids gambling-related businesses from sponsoring its tournaments. It also says the Attorney General wants items to stop being transferable, and that Valve refuses. | Trading and Market sales are what skin sites depend on. Valve says "Transferability is a right we believe should not be taken away" and that a court will decide who is right. | |
| United States | Class actions over loot boxes filed against Valve in Seattle. Two players filed a nationwide class action, Flauto v. Valve (No. 2:26-cv-00788, US District Court for the Western District of Washington), claiming the loot boxes in Counter-Strike, Dota 2 and Team Fortress 2 are illegal gambling under Washington law. More suits followed in the same court, among them Galas v. Valve (No. 2:26-cv-00995) on 24 March 2026. Valve has asked the court to dismiss the class action and the players oppose it; we found no ruling as of 18 November 2026. | The suits ask for money back for people in the US who paid to open boxes and received items worth less than they paid. | |
| United States | New York's Attorney General sues Valve over loot boxes. Attorney General Letitia James sued Valve in the New York State Supreme Court, New York County (Index No. 450952/2026), saying loot boxes in Counter-Strike 2, Team Fortress 2 and Dota 2 are illegal gambling under the state constitution and penal law. The complaint asks for an order stopping it, restitution, disgorgement and a fine of three times Valve's gains. "These features are addictive, harmful, and illegal," James said. | The lawsuit targets the case-opening system itself, and the complaint also describes third-party skin gambling sites. If New York wins, the way cases and skins work for players in New York could change. | |
| Esports | Valve bars skin gambling sponsors from all licensed CS2 events. Valve updated its Counter-Strike Tournament Operation Requirements so that every licensed CS2 tournament, ranked or unranked, must follow the "IP Protection" clause (2.4.e) of its tournament licence. That clause keeps case-opening and skin trading sites off broadcasts and jerseys, and bans sponsors that rely on Valve's game economies or interact with players' Valve inventories. | This rule covers case-opening and skin trading sponsors on team kits and broadcasts at licensed CS2 events. A site's link to a team or event is no sign Valve approves of it. | |
| United Kingdom | UK government publishes a review of skins gambling. The Department for Culture, Media and Sport published a rapid evidence review of skins gambling by researchers at Nottingham Trent University. It says skins gambling sites are not considered legal in Great Britain, where the Gambling Commission has said such sites need a licence, and recommends age checks and stronger enforcement. The review is research, not government policy, and changes no law. | In Great Britain a skin gambling site needs a Gambling Commission licence, and the review notes that many operate without one. | |
| Belgium, Netherlands, France | Genesis Terminals switched on in Belgium, the Netherlands and France. A day after the Genesis Collection launched, Valve let customers in Belgium, the Netherlands and France unseal their Sealed Genesis Terminals. Valve did not say why these three countries were handled separately. | Terminals show the item and its price before you pay, so players in these countries got access to the Genesis Collection a day later than everyone else. |
|
| Netherlands | Dutch regulator moves to collect €840,000 from CSGOFast's operator. The Dutch Gambling Authority (Kansspelautoriteit) found csgofast.com still open to Dutch players at checks on 30 April, 20 May and 12 June 2025, so Gamusoft LP forfeited the maximum €840,000 in penalties. Because it had not paid, the regulator decided to collect the money. | A Dutch player on CSGOFast is using a site the Dutch regulator has ordered to stop serving the Netherlands. |
On CS2Bet: CSGOFast review |
| Worldwide | Valve makes every CS2 trade reversible for 7 days. Valve added Trade Protection: any CS2 item trade can be reversed for 7 days from the Trade History page. In its March 2026 statement Valve lists trade reversal among the features it shipped to discourage gambling sites. | Skins you receive in a trade, including withdrawals from a site, cannot be traded on, sold or moved for 7 days. |
On CS2Bet: CS2 Trade Protection explained |
| Australia | Australia formally warns CSGOFast's and Skin.Club's operators. ACMA formally warned Gamusoft LP (CSGOFast) and Moontain Ltd (Skin.Club) for offering skin gambling services to Australians, in breach of the Interactive Gambling Act 2001 (warnings published July 2025). | Players there are using services the regulator has formally warned. |
On CS2Bet: CSGOFast review |
| Netherlands | Dutch regulator orders CSGOFast's operator to stop serving the Netherlands. The Kansspelautoriteit ordered Gamusoft LP, which runs csgofast.com, to stop offering games of chance to Dutch players without a Dutch licence, on pain of €280,000 a week up to €840,000. Its inspectors found that people in the Netherlands could open accounts, deposit and play, with nothing in place to stop them. The order is dated 2 April 2025; the regulator's Gamusoft LP page lists it under 16 April 2025, and its news item announcing it is dated 17 April 2025. | The Dutch regulator treats a CS2 skin site open to Dutch players without a Dutch licence as illegal gambling. |
On CS2Bet: CSGOFast review |
| Esports | Stage incident at the PGL Major Copenhagen, claimed by a skin gambling site. During the PGL Major Copenhagen, the first CS2 Major, a spectator who rushed the stage was tackled into the trophy, which broke. A skin gambling site claimed responsibility, and the organiser said it would press charges. | Skin gambling sites were common sponsors around CS2 events at the time. Since 8 December 2025 Valve's licence rules keep case-opening and skin trading sponsors off every licensed CS2 event (entry above). |
|
Primary sources come first: court filings, regulators' own decisions and Valve's patch notes and support pages. A press report is used only where no primary text was available to us, and is marked as such. Every link was checked on the date shown; where a page did not load for us, the entry says so.
Lawsuits against Valve that are not about gambling
Searches for "Valve lawsuit" mix gambling cases with others. In the UK, the Competition Appeal Tribunal let Shotbolt v Valve go ahead as a collective claim on 26 January 2026. It is about the commission Steam charges on PC games and in-game content, estimated by the claimant at up to £656 million, and not about cases or skin gambling (CAT judgment, 26 January 2026).
Questions
What is the Valve lawsuit about?
New York's Attorney General says the loot boxes in Counter-Strike 2, Team Fortress 2 and Dota 2, which you pay to open for a random item that can be traded and sold, are illegal gambling under New York's constitution and penal law. The complaint, filed on 25 February 2026, asks the court to stop the practice permanently and to make Valve pay back what New Yorkers lost, give up its gains and pay a fine of three times its gain. Valve denies that its cases are gambling.
What happens to my CS2 skins because of the lawsuit?
Nothing yet: we found no ruling as of 18 November 2026, so cases, trading and the Steam Market work as before. Valve says New York wants items to stop being transferable and that it refuses. If New York wins, the court decides what has to change.
Can I join the Valve class action?
There is nothing to sign up for that we could find as of 18 November 2026. The federal complaints in Seattle ask to represent people in the US who paid to open loot boxes, but no class has been certified and no settlement announced that we found. If a settlement comes, the court-approved notice says who can claim and how. The New York case is brought by the state itself, not by players.
Is CS2 gambling legal?
It depends on where you live, and this page is not legal advice. A few examples from official sources: a review published by the UK government says skins gambling sites are not considered legal in Great Britain without a Gambling Commission licence; the Dutch Gambling Authority ordered a skin site with no Dutch licence to stop serving Dutch players; and Australia's media regulator has formally warned two skin gambling sites' operators. In the United States, New York's Attorney General says Valve's own cases are illegal gambling under state law and Valve disputes it; we found no ruling as of 18 November 2026. Age limits differ too. Check the law where you live, and ask a lawyer if you need a firm answer.
Is Valve being sued over CS2 cases?
Yes. New York's Attorney General sued Valve on 25 February 2026 in the New York State Supreme Court, and players filed class actions in federal court in Seattle from 9 March 2026. Valve denies that its cases are gambling. It asked the New York court to dismiss that case on 18 May 2026, and has also asked the Seattle court to dismiss the class action there. We found no ruling in either as of 18 November 2026. A separate UK claim against Valve (Shotbolt v Valve) is about the commission Steam charges on PC games and in-game content, not about cases.
Can I open cases in Germany or the Netherlands?
Yes, but only through the X-Ray Scanner since 16 March 2026. Valve's rules for players there: you first claim a free, non-tradable Genuine P250 | X-ray, then scan one container at a time to see the item inside before paying. To scan another container you have to buy the item you revealed, and a scanned container is used up. Keyless containers such as Souvenir Packages open without the scanner. This is about opening cases in the game, not about third-party sites, which are a separate question under local law.
What about Belgium and France?
Valve's patch notes do not set out the full case rules for these countries. What they do show is that on 17 September 2025 Valve switched on unsealing of Genesis Terminals for customers in Belgium, the Netherlands and France separately, a day after the terminals launched everywhere else. Check what your own game client offers.
Will Valve stop skin trading?
Valve says no. In its statement of 11 March 2026 it says New York's Attorney General wants items to stop being transferable and that Valve refuses. A court ruling or a new law could still change that, so treat it as an open question.
Why are skin gambling sponsors barred from licensed CS2 events?
Since 8 December 2025 Valve requires every licensed CS2 tournament to follow the IP Protection clause of its tournament licence, which keeps case-opening and skin trading sites off broadcasts and jerseys and bans sponsors that rely on Valve's game economies or interact with players' inventories. ESL Pro Tour brought its team rulebook in line on 7 July 2026.
Has a regulator acted against a CS2 gambling site?
Yes. The Dutch Gambling Authority ordered Gamusoft LP, the operator of CSGOFast, to stop serving Dutch players on 2 April 2025, and on 4 September 2025 decided to collect the €840,000 in penalties it had forfeited. In July 2025 Australia's media regulator formally warned Gamusoft LP over CSGOFast and Moontain Ltd over Skin.Club.
Related: closed CS2 gambling sites · CS2 Trade Protection · CS2 cases · responsible gambling.